
These figures do not settle the argument, and they should be read carefully. They record criminal offences, not the broader climate of statements, demonstrations or rhetoric that critics of the Left are concerned about, and categories such as “foreign ideology” are themselves debated. But they show that the political attention given to the left does not match its share of recorded offences, which supports the Left’s claim that the slogan is being used instrumentally. Left Party chair Ines Schwerdtner called the Junge Union’s campaign “an impertinence,” saying it was “really an impertinence that they instrumentalise this slogan against the Left,” and described the youth organisation as the “right wing” of the party.
The coalition question divides both potential partners. Within the SPD, the four Berlin Bundestag members rejected the statement of the 20 others and support starting negotiations. Their statement argues: “Berlin needs a government capable of acting, one that devotes itself to people’s concrete problems, and not a political debate that closes all doors before serious negotiations have even begun.” They also affirm Israel’s right to exist and the protection of Jewish life. The disagreement is therefore not over principles but over whether talks are a legitimate way to test a partner’s commitment.
The Greens are split as well. Co-leader Franziska Brantner, associated with the more conservative “Realo” wing, told ARD that the Berlin Left “obviously has a problem with antisemitism, also with proximity to organised crime.” She may also fear that red-green-red in Berlin would make a black-green coalition at the federal level harder. Her co-leader, Felix Banaszak, was less critical and even raised the possibility of red-green-red at the federal level at the Green Youth’s national congress. “If these three parties want to have an option to come together after the next federal election,” he said, “then this alliance must not start on the wrong premises.” Yet the Greens’ national leadership has little real influence on the decision in Berlin: “Further decisions are at the state level,” Banaszak reportedly wrote to party members.
Three national implications explain the intensity of the dispute.
First, coalition arithmetic. The federal government is a black-red coalition of the Union and the SPD, and conservatives fear that cooperation with the Left in the capital sets a precedent for the future. Some in the Greens and the SPD, in contrast, see a model for a possible left-of-centre alliance after the next federal election.
Second, the politics of memory. The use of “Never again is now” by rivals shows how a moral commitment becomes a competitive resource. Every actor has to avoid appearing to trivialise antisemitism, which makes pragmatic discussion difficult and raises the cost of any compromise.
Third, party identity. For the SPD, which is struggling nationally, the decision is about whether it allows its Berlin branch to follow a left-leaning path or insists on conformity with the federal strategy. The visible split between the federal and Berlin organisations reveals how limited the centre’s control is.
The coming weeks will show whether the project is feasible. The first test is the Left’s vote at the end of October, which will indicate whether the party can accept the conditions that its prospective partners attach, including those regarding antisemitism and its handling of the Emde case. The second is the content of the coalition negotiations: any agreement will have to include clear statements on Israel, Jewish life and the party’s internal discipline to be credible to sceptics. The third is the reaction of federal politicians, particularly in the SPD, if the talks continue. The fourth is whether the Union’s “firewall” language gains traction among voters or comes to be seen as a campaign tactic.
The Berlin discussion has turned a municipal coalition into a national symbol. At its core lie two legitimate concerns that are often presented as opposites: the obligation to take antisemitism seriously wherever it appears, and the right of parties to negotiate and to be judged on what they actually agree. The statistics suggest that the political focus on the left is disproportionate; the Emde case shows that concerns about specific statements are not invented. The credibility of the eventual coalition, if there is one, will rest on whether it can show that both points are true at once.






Comments